Dec 14 2007
12 Things We Don’t Know About Google Knol
In truth, we don’t know much. Here are a few questions which immediately crossed my mind:
- Once authors create pages, how will they become discovered in Google’s index? That is, will authors have to promote their pages and gather incoming links to achieve a high status for their article?
- Will there be a dedicated ‘knol search’, like Google Blog Search? I think the answer is almost certainly yes.
- How hard will it be to get a beta invite?
- How will the Knol identity system integrate with the rest of the hodge podge that is Google’s ID system. I have far too many Google logins, and most of them don’t talk to each other.
- Will authors be able to embed audio and video content in knols?
- What will the authoring system look like? Will it have any relationship to Google Docs and Spreadsheets?
- What will the revenue split be between Google and knol writers?
- How will Google handle multiple competitive knols on the same topic? I assume the same way they handle competition between web pages on any topic, but do searchers really want to see multiple knol search results in the first couple of pages?
- How will Knol compete with Mahalo, Squidoo and Wikipedia? For one thing, the revenue model sure beats Mahalo. I’d rather get a trickle of income over five years than $10 for writing an article. I know which one will add up to more money.
- Imagine two knols on, say, evolutionary psychology. A global authority and eminent professor writes a knol on the topic, as does a SEO-savvy noob. The professor’s knol is way better, but the noob generates way more incoming links. How will Google handle this?
- The sample knol has a Creative Commons license. How will that impact use and re-use of the article’s content?
- Will authors be able to moderate reviews of their own page? That is, will they be able to only publish the positive ones? I doubt it.







